QuizPlays Daily
  1. Home
  2. Games
  3. Would You Rather Questions
  4. Halloween Would You Rather Questions

Halloween Would You Rather Questions

  • Would You Rather
  • 20 questions
  • Live results

These Halloween would you rather questions are packed with spooky-fun dilemmas about costumes, candy, haunted houses, monsters and trick-or-treating. Pick between two treats (or two tricks) for each question, and as soon as you vote you'll see live results showing how everyone else answered, from the bravest to the most easily spooked. They're a perfect warm-up for Halloween parties, fall festivals, classroom celebrations, pumpkin-carving nights and scary movie marathons.

How to play

To play with friends or family, gather everyone around the candy bowl and take turns reading a question aloud. Each person picks a side, then explains their choice in their spookiest voice. For a party twist, have people move to one side of the room or the other, or hand out a piece of candy to whoever gives the most convincing reason. Kids love defending their picks, so it works just as well at a classroom party as at a grown-up costume bash.

A few tips keep the fun going. Read questions by flashlight or candlelight for extra atmosphere, and pause on any question that splits the group evenly, since those spark the best debates. Ask follow-ups like which costume someone would actually wear or which haunted house they'd dare to walk through first. Once you've played, check how your answers compare with everyone else's votes and see whether your friends are braver, or sweeter, than the rest of the country.

All 20 questions

  1. Would you rather trick-or-treat in a mansion neighborhood or trick-or-treat on a street with spooky decorations?
  2. Would you rather get only full-size candy bars or get twice as much fun-size candy?
  3. Would you rather wear the same costume every Halloween or never be allowed to repeat a costume?
  4. Would you rather spend a night in a haunted house or walk through a corn maze alone at midnight?
  5. Would you rather be a friendly ghost or be a vegetarian vampire?
  6. Would you rather only get candy corn in your bag or only get raisins in your bag?
  7. Would you rather carve the scariest pumpkin on the block or carve the funniest pumpkin on the block?
  8. Would you rather have a pet black cat that talks or have a pet bat that does tricks?
  9. Would you rather win a costume contest or win a pumpkin pie eating contest?
  10. Would you rather live in a castle haunted by polite ghosts or live next door to a werewolf?
  11. Would you rather hand out candy at home or go trick-or-treating with friends?
  12. Would you rather have a costume that lights up or have a costume that makes spooky sounds?
  13. Would you rather ride a witch's broom or ride in a headless horseman's carriage?
  14. Would you rather watch a scary movie alone or tell ghost stories around a campfire?
  15. Would you rather be scared by a jump scare or be creeped out by a slow, eerie sound?
  16. Would you rather go to a pumpkin patch or go on a hayride?
  17. Would you rather have Halloween twice a year or have Halloween last a whole week?
  18. Would you rather dress up as a classic monster or dress up as your favorite cartoon character?
  19. Would you rather trade candy with your friends or keep every piece you collect?
  20. Would you rather make your own costume from scratch or buy the fanciest costume in the store?